bds
|
ba
|
sqft
ac lot
|
car garage
|
|
Investment Properties for Sale in Marysvale, Utah
Marysvale sits in the Sevier River Valley along US-89, roughly 200 miles south of Salt Lake City and about 30 miles north of Panguitch. It's a small town — fewer than 500 residents — but its investment appeal is rooted in exactly that smallness. The area draws ATV and off-road enthusiasts year-round, anchored by the Arapeen OHV Trail system and direct access to the Fishlake National Forest. Vacation rentals in towns like Marysvale consistently outperform larger markets on occupancy-per-listing metrics because supply is thin and the surrounding scenery — the Tushar Mountains rising above 12,000 feet to the west, Big Rock Candy Mountain to the south — keeps drawing repeat visitors who can't find lodging anywhere closer. Cabins, acreage parcels, and older homes priced in the $150,000–$350,000 range make entry costs modest compared to the Moab or St. George markets, which is a meaningful advantage for buyers calculating cash-on-cash returns.
Investment properties in Marysvale come in several flavors: short-term vacation rentals targeting the OHV crowd, longer-term rentals for seasonal workers or remote workers priced out of bigger Utah towns, and raw land held for appreciation as Southern Utah's recreation economy continues expanding. Piute County has minimal short-term rental regulation compared to resort-heavy counties, which lowers the compliance burden for new investors. Water rights, well condition, and septic capacity deserve close attention here — rural Sevier Valley properties carry infrastructure considerations that a Salt Lake suburb purchase simply doesn't. An agent who knows Piute and Sevier County specifics can save you significant due-diligence headaches. Browse the active listings below to see what's currently on the market.
May 2026 · Marysvale market
Live from the Utah MLS — what's actually happening in Marysvale right now.
Median sale
$295,000
2 closed in May 2026
Median DOM
32 days
listing → contract
Sale-to-list
98.0%
of final list price
Unsold inventory
5
active + pending
6 matching · page 1 of 1
Active listings
Prefer the map?
See all 6 investment properties on a map
Pan around Marysvale and refine by drawing your own boundary.
Common questions
About investment properties in Marysvale.
What kinds of investment properties show up in Marysvale? ▾
The mix here leans toward short-term rental cabins, small acreage parcels, fixer-upper bungalows in town, and the occasional roadside commercial building along US-89. With Piute ATV trails and the Paiute OHV system running right through town, cabins and bunkhouses geared toward weekend riders tend to be the most active category.
Is short-term rental allowed in Marysvale? ▾
Marysvale is one of the more STR-friendly small towns in Piute County, largely because tourism from ATV riders, anglers, and Big Rock Candy Mountain visitors drives the local economy. Always verify current town and county rules before closing — regulations can shift, and septic capacity often dictates occupancy caps on rural parcels.
What's the realistic nightly rate for an ATV-trail cabin here? ▾
Well-located cabins sleeping 6-10 with trail access typically rent in the $200-$400/night range during peak ATV season (late spring through October), with lower winter occupancy unless the property markets to snowmobilers. Properties that sleep larger groups and allow machines parked on-site command the top end.
How does Marysvale compare to Beaver or Panguitch for rental returns? ▾
Marysvale has a smaller listing pool but stronger trail-adjacent demand than Beaver, and a longer riding season than higher-elevation Panguitch. Purchase prices also tend to run lower than comparable Sevier County towns, which can help cash-on-cash returns even with thinner overall booking volume.
Are there financing quirks for rural Marysvale properties? ▾
Yes — well, septic, and access road condition all come into play, and some lenders treat cabin-style or log construction more cautiously. USDA Rural Development loans can work for owner-occupied purchases, but pure investment deals usually need a portfolio lender or a larger down payment than urban Wasatch Front comps.
How many investment-grade listings are typically active here? ▾
Marysvale is a small market — inventory often runs in the single digits at any given time, and the best trail-access cabins move quickly when priced right. Setting up a saved search and checking the active listings below regularly is the most practical way to catch new inventory.