bds
|
ba
|
sqft
ac lot
|
car garage
|
|
5+ Bedroom Homes for Sale in Fillmore, Utah
Fillmore sits in Millard County about two hours south of Salt Lake along I-15, where the Pahvant Range meets the western desert. It's a working town of roughly 2,500 people — Utah's original territorial capital — with a slower pace, agricultural roots, and lot sizes that make larger homes genuinely practical. Five-bedroom houses here aren't squeezed onto quarter-acre cul-de-sacs the way they often are along the Wasatch Front. Many sit on a third of an acre to several acres, with room for shops, horses, gardens, or the extended-family living arrangements that are common in Millard County. Pricing reflects the rural location: 5+ bedroom homes in Fillmore typically run well below comparable square footage in Utah County, which is part of why buyers from Provo, Nephi, and even Las Vegas keep an eye on this market.
The inventory tends to skew two directions — older farmhouses and ramblers near downtown that have been added onto over decades, and newer builds on the south and east edges of town with finished basements that push bedroom counts to five, six, or seven. Heating costs matter at this elevation (around 5,100 feet, with real winters), so pay attention to the mechanicals on bigger homes. Fillmore Elementary, Millard Middle, and Millard High serve the area, and the hospital and Maverik make Fillmore the service hub for the surrounding ranching communities. Browse the active 5+ bedroom listings below to see what's currently on the market.
April 2026 · Fillmore market
Live from the Utah MLS — what's actually happening in Fillmore right now.
Median sale
$330,400
3 closed in April 2026
Median DOM
155 days
listing → contract
Sale-to-list
94.4%
of final list price
Unsold inventory
25
active + pending
10 matching · page 1 of 1
Active listings
Prefer the map?
See all 10 5+ bedroom homes on a map
Pan around Fillmore and refine by drawing your own boundary.
Common questions
About 5+ bedroom homes in Fillmore.
How many 5+ bedroom homes are typically for sale in Fillmore at one time? ▾
Inventory in Fillmore is thin — the town only has a few hundred single-family homes total, and 5+ bedroom listings usually number in the single digits at any given moment. If nothing on the current list fits, it's worth setting up an alert; new listings often go under contract within a few weeks when priced reasonably.
What do 5-bedroom homes in Fillmore generally cost? ▾
Pricing varies widely with acreage and condition, but 5+ bedroom homes in Fillmore have recently traded in a range roughly from the upper $300s for older homes needing work to the upper $500s or low $600s for newer builds on larger lots. Homes with shops, irrigation shares, or acreage push higher.
Are most 5-bedroom homes here counting basement bedrooms? ▾
Yes, in almost every case. The standard Fillmore floor plan is a rambler with three bedrooms up and two or three more finished in the basement. Make sure basement bedrooms have conforming egress windows — older homes sometimes don't, which affects appraisals and financing.
Can I find a 5-bedroom home in Fillmore with acreage or room for animals? ▾
Often, yes. Lot sizes on the edges of town frequently run a half-acre to five acres, and properties zoned for horses or small livestock turn up regularly. Water rights and secondary irrigation shares are worth asking about — they meaningfully affect what you can do with the land.
What's the commute situation for buyers working elsewhere? ▾
Fillmore is right on I-15, so Nephi is about 35 minutes, Provo runs about 75 minutes, and Cedar City is around 90 minutes south. It's not a daily Salt Lake commute, but it works well for remote workers, hybrid schedules, or trades that move between job sites in central Utah.
Are larger homes here usually on natural gas or propane? ▾
Inside Fillmore city limits, natural gas service through Dominion is the norm. Homes on acreage just outside town are more likely to be on propane, which is a real cost factor for heating a 3,500+ square foot home through a Millard County winter. Always check the utility setup before writing an offer.