Zillow Market Report

Relocating to Utah's beautiful southern region? This guide dives into the key differences between two popular cities: St. George and Hurricane. From accessibility and amenities to schools and outdoor recreation, we’ll help you determine which community aligns better with your lifestyle.

Introduction to St. George and Hurricane

St. George, a medium-sized city with a population of around 103,000, is centrally located in Washington County. This city boasts well-planned neighborhoods where most amenities are within a 5-10 minute drive. While some communities within St. George offer walkable areas, having a car is generally necessary to navigate the city efficiently. Public transportation and ride-sharing options like Uber are available but not as practical as in larger cities.

On the other hand, Hurricane is a smaller city with a population of about 23,000. Spanning 52 square miles, it’s relatively easy to get across town in under five minutes. However, like St. George, living without a car in Hurricane would be challenging. The proximity of these two cities—just 12 miles apart—means that many amenities and recreational opportunities are shared between them, making both attractive options for potential residents.

City Sizes & Accessibility

St. George, with its larger population and 72 square miles of area, offers more walkable neighborhoods compared to Hurricane. Despite this, driving remains essential for daily activities. The city’s infrastructure supports quick commutes, typically no more than 10 minutes apart.

Hurricane, being smaller, makes it easy to get around quickly by car. However, the city lacks the walkability and public transport options that you might find in larger urban areas. Residents often rely on their vehicles to access daily necessities and amenities.

Shopping & Amenities

St. George shines with a variety of shopping and dining options. Big box retailers like Walmart, Costco, and Target are readily available, as well as grocery stores such as Albertsons and Smith's. For those seeking healthier choices, stores like Harmon's and Natural Grocers offer excellent selections. The city also boasts a growing number of restaurants catering to diverse tastes.

Hurricane, in contrast, has more limited shopping and dining options. While there are a few grocery stores and restaurants, residents often drive to St. George or Washington for a wider selection. This makes St. George a more convenient option for those who prefer shorter commutes for errands and dining out.

Education: Schools and After-School Activities

Schools

Washington County School District serves both St. George and Hurricane, but St. George offers a broader range of educational opportunities. The city is home to 14 elementary schools, seven intermediate and middle schools, and five high schools. In contrast, Hurricane has just two elementary schools, two intermediate and middle schools, and one high school.

For families with school-aged children, St. George provides more choices for both public and private education. This variety can be a significant factor for those prioritizing education in their relocation decision.

After-School Activities

St. George excels in offering a wide range of after-school activities, thanks to its larger size and more extensive resources. From sports to arts and other extracurricular programs, children in St. George have numerous options to explore.

In comparison, Hurricane's smaller size means fewer after-school activity options. Many families in Hurricane find themselves driving to St. George to access these programs. This can be a crucial consideration for parents looking to keep their children engaged and active outside of school hours.

Fitness Options: Gyms and Recreation

For those who prioritize fitness, the variety of gyms in St. George is a definite advantage. From commercial gyms like VASA Fitness to specialized ones like Fitness Culture and Summit Athletic Club, there's something for everyone. Fitness Culture, for example, is known for its high-end equipment and athlete-focused environment, while Summit offers a more family-friendly atmosphere with amenities like a pool and daycare.

In contrast, Hurricane has fewer gym options, which can sometimes be crowded. Performance Fitness and Anytime Fitness are the main gyms, along with a handful of smaller CrossFit facilities. Many residents find it worthwhile to drive to St. George for better gym facilities. This can be a significant consideration if fitness is a central part of your daily routine.

Utilities and Cost of Living

Utility costs are an essential factor when choosing between St. George and Hurricane. Both cities offer relatively affordable utility rates compared to the national average. In St. George, the city provides water, sewer, and trash services, typically costing around $90 per month. Power is supplied by either the City of St. George Power or Dixie Power, with Dixie Power being the cheaper option at approximately 6 cents per kilowatt-hour.

In Hurricane, utility costs are similar. The city provides water, sewer, trash, and power, though only one subdivision falls under Dixie Power's coverage. The standard rate for electricity in Hurricane is about 9 cents per kilowatt-hour, which is still affordable compared to many other states. Overall, both cities offer competitive utility rates, but living within Dixie Power's service area can lead to additional savings.

Weather Comparison

The weather is another critical factor to consider. St. George, situated at an elevation of 2,800 feet, tends to be warmer, especially in the summer months. It’s not uncommon for temperatures to reach the high 90s or even 100s during peak summer. However, winter temperatures are milder, making it a comfortable place to live year-round.

Hurricane, at a slightly higher elevation of 3,200 feet, experiences cooler temperatures and is known for its windy conditions. During the summer, Hurricane can be about 5 degrees cooler than St. George, but in the winter, the wind chill can make it feel significantly colder. The saying goes, "Cedar City sucks and Hurricane blows," highlighting the windy nature of Hurricane.

Ultimately, if you prefer warmer and more stable weather, St. George might be the better option. However, if you enjoy cooler temperatures and don’t mind the wind, Hurricane could be more appealing.

Real Estate Market Insights

When it comes to real estate, both St. George and Hurricane offer unique advantages. Historically, Hurricane has provided more value for money, offering larger homes at lower prices compared to St. George. However, the housing market has shifted in recent years, and the gap between the two cities has narrowed.

In 2024, the median sale price in St. George appears lower, but this can be misleading. When comparing homes in the same price range, you are likely to get a larger or more updated home in Hurricane. For example, a $650,000 home in Hurricane might offer more square footage and newer amenities compared to a similarly priced home in St. George.

For those prioritizing value and space, Hurricane remains a strong contender. On the other hand, St. George’s proximity to amenities, schools, and recreational activities might justify the higher cost for many buyers. It’s essential to weigh these factors based on your personal preferences and lifestyle needs.

Outdoor Recreation Opportunities

One of the most appealing aspects of Southern Utah is its natural beauty and abundant outdoor recreation opportunities. St. George is often referred to as the golf capital of Utah, boasting numerous public and private golf courses. Top-ranked courses include Snow Canyon, The Ledges, Dixie Red Hills, Sunbrook, and Bloomington Country Club. For those who enjoy hiking and biking, St. George offers countless trails, with some easily accessible right from downtown. The Sugarloaf hike is a popular choice, and many subdivisions have trails just steps away from home.

St. George also provides access to off-road trails and the expansive Arizona Strip at the end of River Road. This area offers a vast network of trails that can take you across multiple states, making it a paradise for off-road enthusiasts.

Hurricane, on the other hand, is a haven for off-road recreation. Sand Hollow State Park is a major attraction, featuring thousands of acres of sand dunes, miles of desert trails, and rock crawling routes for all skill levels. The park also includes Sand Hollow and Quail Creek Reservoirs, perfect for boating, swimming, and fishing. The Links at Sand Hollow, Sky Ranch, and Copper Rock golf courses offer breathtaking views and lush greens, making them a hit among golfers.

In Hurricane, many off-road vehicles can be made street legal, allowing residents to drive directly from their homes to the desert. This convenience makes it easy to enjoy outdoor activities even on weekdays. Dixie Springs is a popular neighborhood for off-road enthusiasts, offering proximity to both the desert and the lake.

Final Thoughts: Which City is Right for You?

Deciding between St. George and Hurricane ultimately depends on your lifestyle and priorities. Both cities have their unique advantages and a few drawbacks.

If you prefer a medium-sized city with short commutes, numerous amenities, and a wide range of schools and after-school activities, St. George might be the better choice for you. The city offers a variety of gyms, shopping options, and dining experiences, making daily life convenient and enjoyable. The warmer, more stable weather in St. George is also a plus for those who prefer milder winters.

On the other hand, if you value a closer connection to nature, enjoy off-road recreation, and don't mind a 20-minute drive for shopping and dining, Hurricane could be the ideal fit. The city offers more value for money in real estate, larger homes, and a small-town feel. The proximity to Sand Hollow State Park and other outdoor attractions makes it a paradise for adventure seekers.

Having lived in both cities, we can confidently say that you can't go wrong with either choice. Each city offers a unique lifestyle, catering to different preferences and needs. Consider what matters most to you and your family, and you'll find the perfect place to call home in Southern Utah.

Posted by

Related Articles: