Catalina Bay Homes For Sale

Catalina Bay is a new-construction subdivision in Saratoga Springs, with homes built predominantly since 2020 and a median living area of 4,432 square feet on quarter-acre lots. Sales data is limited here — just one closing recorded in the past year, at $734,000 after 25 days on market and a 97.87% sale-to-list ratio — so pricing trends should be read with caution given the small sample. New listings over the past several months have ranged widely, from $539,000 to $1.2 million, reflecting a mix of home sizes and finishes still coming to market. All homes feed Westlake High, with 91% assigned to Lake Mountain Middle, while elementary assignment splits between Harbor Point (61%) and Sage Hills (the remainder). A modest monthly HOA fee of $55 applies community-wide.