Catalina Bay Homes For Sale

Catalina Bay is a small, newly built subdivision in Saratoga Springs where every home on record dates to 2020 or later, with an average build year of 2022 and a median living area of 4,432 sqft on roughly 0.23-acre lots. Sales activity is limited — just three closings over the past year — but recorded sale prices ranged from $650,000 in May 2025 to $1.12M in June 2025, with the most recent sale at $734,000 in May 2026 after 25 days on market. New listings since late 2025 have been priced between $750,000 and $1.2M, suggesting an upper-bracket inventory mix. HOA dues run a modest $55 per month, and every home feeds Westlake High, with most assigned to Lake Mountain Middle (83%) and elementary students split between Harbor Point and Sage Hills.