bds
|
ba
|
sqft
ac lot
|
car garage
|
|
4+ Bedroom Homes for Sale in Fish Haven, Utah
Fish Haven sits on the Idaho border at the south end of Bear Lake, but the Utah side of this small community draws families looking for vacation cabins, second homes, and full-time residences with room to spread out. Four-bedroom-and-up homes here tend to fall into two camps: lakefront or lake-view properties built as multi-generational getaways, and larger primary residences on bigger lots tucked back toward the foothills of the Bear River Range. With the turquoise water of Bear Lake a short walk or drive away, sleeping space matters — buyers want bunk rooms for grandkids, guest rooms for ski-season visitors, and enough bathrooms to handle a full house in July without a line at the door.
Elevation here runs around 5,900 feet, so winters are real (snow, plowed roads, and a heating bill to match) and summers are dry and warm with cool nights. Most 4-bed homes are wood-frame builds from the 1990s through 2020s, often with walkout basements, attached garages sized for boats or snowmobiles, and propane heat since natural gas service is limited. Garden City is five minutes north for groceries and restaurants, Logan is about 45 minutes over Logan Canyon, and Salt Lake City International is roughly 2.5 hours by car. Inventory is thin year-round and turns over fastest in late spring before the summer season kicks in. Browse the active 4+ bedroom listings below to see what Fish Haven currently has on the market.
May 2026 · Fish Haven market
Live from the Utah MLS — what's actually happening in Fish Haven right now.
Median sale
$747,000
2 closed in May 2026
Median DOM
26 days
listing → contract
Sale-to-list
94.5%
of final list price
Unsold inventory
24
active + pending
24 matching · page 1 of 1
Active listings
Prefer the map?
See all 24 4+ bedroom homes on a map
Pan around Fish Haven and refine by drawing your own boundary.
Common questions
About 4+ bedroom homes in Fish Haven.
How many 4+ bedroom homes are typically for sale in Fish Haven at one time? ▾
Fish Haven is a small community, so active inventory is usually limited — often just a handful of 4-bedroom-or-larger homes on the Utah side at any given moment. Listings tend to pick up between April and June as sellers position for the summer Bear Lake season. If nothing matches today, it's worth saving a search and checking weekly.
Are most 4-bedroom homes here used as primary residences or vacation properties? ▾
Both, but vacation and second-home use is heavy. Many larger homes are owned by families from the Wasatch Front, Cache Valley, or out of state who use them on weekends and holidays. That's part of why bedroom count matters so much — buyers want to sleep 10–14 people comfortably during summer weeks.
What price range should I expect for a 4+ bedroom home in Fish Haven? ▾
Pricing varies widely based on lake proximity. Off-water 4-bedroom homes on standard lots commonly run in the high $500Ks to $900Ks, while lakefront or lake-view 4+ bedroom properties can range from roughly $1.2M to $3M+ depending on frontage, square footage, and finishes.
Do 4-bedroom homes in Fish Haven usually include HOA access to the beach? ▾
Many do. Several subdivisions on the Utah side carry HOA membership that includes private beach access, boat storage, or a community dock — which significantly affects value. Always confirm what the HOA conveys with the property and review current dues before writing an offer.
What should I check on a larger home regarding water, septic, and heat? ▾
Most Fish Haven homes are on septic systems and either culinary water-share or community water, not city utilities. Larger homes mean larger septic loads, so septic size, age, and last pump date matter. Heat is typically propane forced-air or in-floor radiant — ask for the tank ownership status (rented vs. owned) and recent fill costs.
Is short-term rental allowed for 4+ bedroom homes here? ▾
Short-term rental rules depend on the specific subdivision and Rich County regulations, and some HOAs restrict or prohibit nightly rentals. Larger homes are attractive STR candidates because of their sleeping capacity, but verify CC&Rs and any county permit requirements before assuming rental income is on the table.