Arrowhead Park Homes For Sale

Arrowhead Park is a small, newly built subdivision in Payson, with an average construction year of 2023 and most homes dating to 2020 or later; units are compact, with a median living area of 1,417 square feet on lots around 1,306 square feet, and a monthly HOA fee of $120. Sales activity is thin—only four closings recorded in the past year—but prices have moved higher, from $322,000 in February 2026 to $454,945 in May and $370,000 in June, with days on market ranging from 13 to 49 and sale-to-list ratios near or slightly above 100%. All homes here feed Barnett Elementary, while middle and high school assignments split, with Payson Jr Middle and Payson High serving roughly half to just over half of residents and Salem Jr Middle and Salem Hills High serving the rest. Given the limited sample size, buyers and sellers should treat pricing trends here as directional rather than definitive.