bds
|
ba
|
sqft
ac lot
|
car garage
|
|
Investment Properties for Sale in Payson, Utah
Payson sits at the south end of Utah County along the I-15 corridor, close enough to Provo and the growing Silicon Slopes job market to pull steady rental demand, but priced well below Provo or Lehi. That gap is the whole story for investors here: a three- or four-bedroom home that might run $550,000 in Lehi still trades in the mid-$400s in Payson, while rents track close behind because tenants commute up the freeway to tech and manufacturing jobs in Orem, Provo, and American Fork. Add in Payson High School, the historic downtown core, and easy access to Spanish Fork Canyon and Utah Lake, and you get a tenant pool that includes young families, BYU and UVU-adjacent renters, and workers at the Nucor and Amazon facilities nearby.
Inventory here leans toward single-family homes on quarter-acre lots and a growing number of newer-build duplexes and townhomes in the neighborhoods off 800 South and Arrowhead Trail — both attractive to buyers who want a rental property that also doubles as a starter home if plans change. Older homes near Main Street and Peteetneet Park sometimes come up with mother-in-law basements already plumbed for a second kitchen, which matters if house-hacking or long-term rental splits are part of the plan. Utah County's landlord-friendly climate and Payson's lower property tax rate compared to Salt Lake County add to the numbers working. Browse the active listings below to see what's currently on the market.
August 2026 · Payson market
Live from the Utah MLS — what's actually happening in Payson right now.
Median sale
$622,000
20 closed in August 2026
Median DOM
71 days
listing → contract
Sale-to-list
97.9%
of final list price
Unsold inventory
114
active + pending
14 matching · page 1 of 1
Active listings
Prefer the map?
See all 14 investment properties on a map
Pan around Payson and refine by drawing your own boundary.
Common questions
About investment properties in Payson.
What kind of rental returns can investors expect in Payson? ▾
Single-family rentals in Payson typically lease in the $1,800–$2,400 range depending on size and condition, with 3-bed/2-bath homes near downtown and the Westfield area being the steadiest performers. Cap rates tend to run tighter than older industrial markets, but appreciation has been strong thanks to Silicon Slopes spillover and the Payson Temple drawing buyers south. Most investors here underwrite for long-term hold rather than high cash flow on day one.
Does Payson allow short-term rentals like Airbnb? ▾
Payson City requires a business license for short-term rentals and they're restricted in most residential zones, so STR plays are limited compared to Park City or Moab. Investors targeting nightly rentals usually look at properties with the right zoning overlay or focus on mid-term furnished rentals for traveling nurses at Mountain View Hospital and contractors working Utah County projects. Always verify current zoning with the city before writing an offer.
Are there fixer-uppers and value-add opportunities on the Payson MLS? ▾
Yes — the older grid south of Main Street and around 100 North has a decent supply of 1940s–1970s homes that trade at a discount to newer Salem Hills or Mountain Vista inventory. These are the typical BRRRR candidates: bring kitchens and baths up to date, add a basement bedroom or ADU where allowed, and rent or refinance. Lot sizes are often generous, which helps resale.
What about multi-family or duplex investments? ▾
Pure multi-family inventory is thin in Payson — most of what hits the MLS is 2–4 unit older properties near the city center or single-family homes with a legal basement apartment. Accessory dwelling units became easier to permit under recent Utah state law, so house-hacking a primary with a basement rental is a common entry strategy for first-time investors here.
Why Payson specifically instead of Spanish Fork or Salem? ▾
Payson still has a lower entry price than Spanish Fork and significantly cheaper than Salem, while sitting right on I-15 with quick access to the tech corridor in Lehi and American Fork. The Payson Temple, hospital, and Nebo School District anchor long-term tenant demand, and Highway 6 traffic toward Carbon County brings consistent demand for workforce housing.
How competitive is the investor market here right now? ▾
Cash and conventional investor offers compete with owner-occupants on anything priced under roughly $400K, so well-priced rentals move quickly. Above that price point, deals sit longer and there's more room to negotiate repairs and closing costs. Working with an agent who tracks days-on-market by neighborhood helps you spot the homes that are actually negotiable.