bds
|
ba
|
sqft
ac lot
|
car garage
|
|
5+ Bedroom Homes for Sale in Payson, Utah
Payson sits at the south end of Utah County where the valley floor meets the Nebo Loop, and it has quietly become one of the more practical spots along the Wasatch Front for larger families. Five-bedroom homes here tend to fall into two camps: newer two-story builds in subdivisions like Mountain View Estates, Gladstan, and the developments climbing the benches above Salem Hills, and older farmhouse-style properties on bigger lots closer to Main Street and Peteetneet. The newer construction usually delivers a main-floor bedroom or office, three or four bedrooms upstairs, and a finished or framed basement that pushes total counts to five, six, or seven. Pricing generally runs lower than equivalent square footage in Spanish Fork, Springville, or Saratoga Springs, which is a big part of why multi-generational households and families with four-plus kids keep landing here.
The practical draw is space without the Lehi or Draper price tag, plus quick access to I-15, the Payson Hospital, and the Nebo School District (Payson High, Mt. Nebo Junior High, and several elementaries feed the area). Summers are warm and dry, winters are milder than Heber or Park City but still get real snow, and the canyon access at the south end of town is genuinely useful for fishing, ATV trips, and fall color drives. Larger homes in Payson also frequently include RV parking, three-car garages, and lots big enough for a trampoline, a garden, and a dog — things that get harder to find further north. Browse the active listings below to see what's currently on the market.
May 2026 · Payson market
Live from the Utah MLS — what's actually happening in Payson right now.
Median sale
$510,000
29 closed in May 2026
Median DOM
42 days
listing → contract
Sale-to-list
99.3%
of final list price
Unsold inventory
130
active + pending
28 matching · page 1 of 2
Active listings
Prefer the map?
See all 28 5+ bedroom homes on a map
Pan around Payson and refine by drawing your own boundary.
Common questions
About 5+ bedroom homes in Payson.
What's the typical price range for a 5-bedroom home in Payson? ▾
Most 5-bedroom homes in Payson currently trade between roughly $500,000 and $750,000, depending on age, lot size, and basement finish. Newer builds in the benches above town and in Salem-adjacent subdivisions push toward the upper end, while older homes closer to Main Street or on the west side of I-15 often come in lower. Larger acreage or horse property can run higher.
Are most 5-bedroom homes in Payson two-story or rambler floor plans? ▾
Both are common. Newer construction from the last 10–15 years leans heavily two-story with three or four bedrooms upstairs plus a main-floor or basement bedroom. Ramblers with finished basements are easier to find in the older neighborhoods near Peteetneet and on the south end near the canyon, and they tend to appeal to buyers who want a main-floor primary suite.
Do 5+ bedroom homes in Payson usually include a basement apartment or mother-in-law setup? ▾
A fair number do. Payson allows accessory apartments under city ordinance with the proper permits, and many larger homes were built or finished with a separate basement entrance, second kitchen, and dedicated laundry. If multi-generational living or rental income matters, look specifically for listings noting a legal accessory unit rather than just a finished basement.
Which schools serve larger family homes in Payson? ▾
Payson is part of the Nebo School District. Most of the city feeds into Payson High and Mt. Nebo Junior High, with elementaries including Wilson, Park View, Barnett, and Taylor depending on the neighborhood. Homes on the east bench typically have shorter drives to the newer schools, while west-side neighborhoods sit closer to Wilson and the older campuses.
How long is the commute from Payson to Provo, Lehi, or Salt Lake? ▾
Provo is about 15–20 minutes up I-15, Lehi/Silicon Slopes runs 30–40 minutes depending on traffic, and downtown Salt Lake is roughly an hour outside rush hour. The FrontRunner station in Payson also gives commuters a rail option north to Provo, Lehi, and Salt Lake without driving the freeway.
Are larger lots and RV parking common with 5-bedroom Payson homes? ▾
Yes, more so than in northern Utah County. Quarter-acre lots are standard in newer subdivisions, and half-acre or larger lots show up regularly in older parts of town and on the south and east edges. RV pads, three-car garages, and gated side yards are frequent features at this size, which is part of why outdoor-recreation families gravitate to Payson.