bds
|
ba
|
sqft
ac lot
|
car garage
|
|
5+ Bedroom Homes for Sale in Island Park, Utah
[{"intro":"
Island Park sits at about 6,300 feet on the Idaho-Utah recreation corridor leading into Yellowstone's west entrance, and the housing stock reflects that — large cabins and lodge-style homes built to sleep big groups. Five-bedroom-plus properties here are usually designed around hosting: bunk rooms, lofts, oversized great rooms, mudrooms sized for ski gear and snowmobile suits, and three-car garages that double as toy storage. Buyers come for Henry's Lake, the Buffalo and Henry's Fork rivers, hundreds of miles of groomed snowmobile trails in winter, and quick access to Yellowstone, West Yellowstone, and Big Sky.
Because so many larger homes in the area double as vacation rentals, you'll see a mix of turnkey-furnished cabins with proven nightly-rental income alongside private family compounds that have never been listed for rent. Subdivisions like Island Park Village, Shotgun, and the Henry's Lake areas each have their own character, HOA rules, and rental policies, so it pays to compare the fine print before narrowing your search. Winter access varies too — some roads are plowed year-round while others switch to snowmobile-only from December through April, which directly affects how the property can be used and rented. The listings below show currently active 5+ bedroom homes in the Island Park market; scroll through to compare layouts, lot sizes, and rental status, and reach out when you want a closer look at a specific property.
"}]June 2026 · Island Park market
Live from the Utah MLS — what's actually happening in Island Park right now.
Median sale
$1,110,000
1 closed in June 2026
Median DOM
—
listing → contract
Sale-to-list
93.7%
of final list price
Unsold inventory
3
active + pending
1 matching · page 1 of 1
Active listings
Prefer the map?
See all 1 5+ bedroom homes on a map
Pan around Island Park and refine by drawing your own boundary.
Common questions
About 5+ bedroom homes in Island Park.
Who typically buys 5+ bedroom homes in Island Park? ▾
The bulk of larger Island Park homes sell as second homes or vacation rentals, not primary residences. Buyers are usually families from the Wasatch Front, Idaho Falls, or out-of-state who want enough beds to host extended family, ski groups in winter, or summer crowds heading to Henry's Lake and Yellowstone.
Can a 5-bedroom Island Park home be used as a short-term rental? ▾
Yes, much of the Island Park area allows nightly rentals, which is why larger floor plans dominate new construction here. Sleep counts of 12-16+ rent well year-round given proximity to Yellowstone's west entrance, snowmobile trails, and the lake. Always verify the specific subdivision's CC&Rs and any HOA rental rules before writing an offer.
What price range should I expect for 5+ bedroom homes here? ▾
Larger cabins and lodge-style homes in Island Park generally run from the upper $600s into the $1.5M+ range depending on lot, finishes, and whether the home is turnkey-furnished. Waterfront or trail-access properties carry a clear premium over interior lots.
Are these homes built for year-round use? ▾
Many newer 5+ bedroom builds are fully insulated, heated, and plumbed for winter use, but older A-frames and seasonal cabins still exist on the market. Snow loads run heavy at this elevation (around 6,300 ft), so check roof construction, heat tape, and whether water lines are buried below frost line.
How far is Island Park from major airports and services? ▾
Idaho Falls Regional Airport is roughly 90 minutes southwest, and Bozeman is about 2 hours north. West Yellowstone sits 20-25 minutes away for groceries, dining, and the park entrance. Day-to-day services in Island Park itself are limited, which is part of the appeal for buyers wanting a quieter base.
What should I check on the inspection for a large cabin? ▾
Focus on the well and septic (most properties are off municipal systems), the condition of the roof and snow management, propane tank ownership vs. lease, and any deferred maintenance on decks and exterior stain. For homes used as rentals, also ask for occupancy and revenue history.