bds
|
ba
|
sqft
ac lot
|
car garage
|
|
4+ Bedroom Homes for Sale in Rexburg, Utah
Rexburg sits in the Upper Snake River Valley at about 4,865 feet of elevation, with BYU-Idaho anchoring the town's economy and shaping much of its housing demand. Four-bedroom homes here serve two very different buyer pools: young families settling near good elementary schools like Kennedy, Lincoln, and Burton, and investors picking up properties zoned for student housing within walking distance of campus. Winters are real — January lows regularly drop below zero — so attached garages, finished basements, and high-efficiency furnaces are features worth paying attention to as you compare listings. Summers are dry and mild, which keeps yard maintenance reasonable and makes the deep lots in subdivisions like Mariah Estates and Hidden Valley genuinely usable.
Pricing on larger Rexburg homes has stayed more accessible than comparable square footage along the Wasatch Front, with most 4-bedroom houses trading between the mid $300s and the high $400s depending on age, basement finish, and lot size. Newer construction on the south and west sides of town tends to come with three-car garages, open main floors, and unfinished basements that buyers can complete later for additional bedrooms or a mother-in-law setup. If you're relocating from Utah for a BYU-Idaho job or wanting to be closer to family in the area, the drive to Salt Lake is about four hours and Idaho Falls Regional Airport is 35 minutes south. Browse the active listings below to see what's currently on the market.
February 2026 · Rexburg market
Live from the Utah MLS — what's actually happening in Rexburg right now.
Median sale
$215,000
1 closed in February 2026
Median DOM
19 days
listing → contract
Sale-to-list
102.4%
of final list price
Unsold inventory
—
active + pending
1 matching · page 1 of 1
Active listings
Prefer the map?
See all 1 4+ bedroom homes on a map
Pan around Rexburg and refine by drawing your own boundary.
Common questions
About 4+ bedroom homes in Rexburg.
Why are 4+ bedroom homes popular in Rexburg? ▾
Rexburg has a young family demographic driven by BYU-Idaho, and many households include three or more kids plus space for visiting grandparents or returned missionaries. Larger floor plans also work well for student rentals near campus, where four bedrooms can be leased by the room under city housing rules.
What do 4-bedroom homes typically cost in Rexburg? ▾
Most 4-bedroom single-family homes in Rexburg fall in the mid $300s to high $400s, with newer builds in subdivisions like Mariah Estates, Hidden Valley, and The Heights pushing into the $500s and above. Older homes closer to downtown or near the university tend to price lower per square foot.
Are these homes zoned for student rentals? ▾
It depends on the address. Rexburg has specific student housing zones (mostly within walking distance of BYU-Idaho), and homes outside those zones are limited to single-family occupancy. If rental income matters to your purchase, verify zoning with the city before writing an offer.
Do most 4+ bedroom Rexburg homes have basements? ▾
Yes. Full basements are standard in the area because of the cold winters and the way local builders pour foundations below the frost line. Many of the 4-bedroom counts you'll see in the MLS include two or three bedrooms upstairs plus additional bedrooms finished in the basement.
How is the commute from larger Rexburg neighborhoods to BYU-Idaho or Idaho Falls? ▾
Most Rexburg subdivisions are within a 5-10 minute drive of campus, and Idaho Falls sits about 30 minutes south on US-20. Newer growth on the south and west sides of town keeps that commute manageable even in winter weather.
Should I note that Rexburg is in Idaho, not Utah? ▾
Yes — Rexburg is in Madison County, Idaho, about 90 minutes north of Logan. The page title reflects how it's grouped on our site, but property taxes, state income tax, and recording procedures all follow Idaho rules, which are generally friendlier to homeowners than Utah's.