Brookside Homes For Sale

Brookside is a small Payson subdivision built predominantly between 2000 and 2009, with homes averaging a 2003 build year, 2,045 square feet of living space, and a modest lot near 0.14 acres; a low $17 monthly HOA fee applies. Sales activity stays light, with only 16 listings over the past year and monthly sold counts typically ranging from zero to four homes, so pricing swings month to month — the most recent close in July 2026 landed at a median of $410,000 after 28 days on market, down from $595,000 in May. Sale-to-list ratios have generally run at or near 100%, indicating homes are pricing accurately for the market. Schooling here is fairly consistent: 98% of homes feed Payson High and 81% feed Spring Lake Elementary, though middle school splits between Payson Jr Middle (63%) and Mt. Nebo Middle. Given the limited sample size each month, buyers and sellers should treat any single month's median price as a narrow snapshot rather than a broader trend.