Homes Under $500,000 in Monticello, Utah

Search Homes
Price
Property type
Home Features
More

Filters

Finding an affordable home in southeastern Utah's scenic San Juan County is entirely possible in Monticello, where properties under $500K offer excellent value for families, retirees, and outdoor enthusiasts alike. This charming mountain town sits at over 7,000 feet elevation, providing four distinct seasons and serving as an ideal gateway to some of Utah's most spectacular recreation areas. With this budget, buyers can discover everything from cozy single-family homes with mountain views to properties with acreage perfect for those seeking a more rural lifestyle.

Monticello's affordable housing market appeals to buyers looking to escape higher-priced urban areas without sacrificing quality of life. The town offers essential amenities including schools, healthcare facilities, and local shops, while nearby attractions like the Abajo Mountains, Canyonlands National Park, and countless hiking and ATV trails provide endless outdoor recreation opportunities. Many homes in this price range feature generous lot sizes, mature landscaping, and the peaceful atmosphere that makes small-town Utah living so appealing.

Browse our current listings of homes under $500K in Monticello to find your perfect match in this welcoming community. Our experienced local agents understand the Monticello market and can help you navigate the buying process, answer questions about specific neighborhoods, and identify properties that meet your needs and budget. Contact us today to schedule viewings or learn more about making Monticello your new home.

View Homes Under $500K in Monticello, Utah


To buy in Monticello, Utah call us directly at 801-410-7917


34 Homes For Sale in MONTICELLO Utah

280 W URANIUM DR, Monticello UT 84535

280 W URANIUM DR
Monticello UT 84535

GREAT NEW STARTER HOME! Step into this freshly updated home featuring brand new flooring, carpet, appliances, furnace, water heater, and lighting throughout. Th...

  • 1974 Sq Ft

  • 5

  • 2

$289,900

123 E HICKMAN FLATS RD, Monticello UT 84535

123 E HICKMAN FLATS RD
Monticello UT 84535

Perfect off-grid getaway or a refuge to call home. Solar power, propane, well, and septic installed. High speed fiber internet provided by Emery Telcom. 13.9 a...

  • 400 Sq Ft

  • 1

  • 1

$235,000

14.9k

481 W OAK CREST DR, Monticello UT 84535

481 W OAK CREST DR
Monticello UT 84535

Excellent location in fun neighborhood. You will love this cute 2-bedroom, 1.5-bath home in Monticello with room for your hobbies! There are recent updates incl...

  • 1346 Sq Ft

  • 2

  • 2

  • 2

$289,000

10.0k

, Monticello UT 84535


Monticello UT 84535

Discover 248.95 acres of beautiful, versatile land for sale in Eastland, Utah - the perfect blend of income potential, recreation, and rural living. This produc...

  • 248.95 Acres

$274,000

, Monticello UT 84535


Monticello UT 84535

Own a beautiful 224.34-acre piece of the quiet Eastland community, perfectly located between monticello and dove creek. This expansive property offers the ideal...

  • 224.34 Acres

$247,000

33 ROSIE LN, Monticello UT 84535

33 ROSIE LN
Monticello UT 84535

True off the grid living with cabin, 32 trailer and even a bunker. Located between Monticello and Blanding on secluded 9.47 beautiful acres. The cabin with most...

  • 1590 Sq Ft

  • 3

  • 3

$255,000

1500 E HWY 491, Monticello UT 84535

1500 E HWY 491
Monticello UT 84535

Looking for ultimate privacy and land close to town? Look no further! This large, 7 acre property is nestled in the trees just off HWY 491. Home has 2 bedroom...

  • 840 Sq Ft

  • 2

  • 2

$275,000

10.0k

165 E 200 S, Monticello UT 84535

165 E 200 S
Monticello UT 84535

Dont miss out on this cozy 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home, with many recent updates including new paint, laminate flooring, interior doors, ceiling lights and fans,...

  • 1440 Sq Ft

  • 3

  • 2

  • 1

$319,900

39.1k

1250 W SUMMIT RD, Monticello UT 84535

1250 W SUMMIT RD
Monticello UT 84535

Eighty acres of open sky and unspoiled terrain offer a peaceful escape in the heart of San Juan County. Zoned agricultural and never before developed, this prop...

  • 80.00 Acres

$125,000

, Monticello UT 84535


Monticello UT 84535

Discover 61 acres of beautiful, versatile land for sale in Eastland, Utah - the perfect blend of income potential, recreation, and rural living. This productive...

  • 61.00 Acres

$122,000

64 S 200 W, Monticello UT 84535

64 S 200 W
Monticello UT 84535

Charming bungalow with modern updates throughout! The best of old style and charm mixed with modern open sized family and living rooms. Enjoy a fully refreshed...

  • 2730 Sq Ft

  • 5

  • 3

$329,900

1 N BUG PT, Monticello UT 84535

1 N BUG PT
Monticello UT 84535

Escape to unparalleled serenity in this secluded parcel of land, bordered on the east and the south by BLM land. Imagine waking to panoramic vistas encompassing...

  • 80.00 Acres

$119,000

20.0k

, Monticello UT 84535


Monticello UT 84535

10 acres located just minutes from Monticello, Utah. This property offers breathtaking views of the Abajo Mountains and surrounding red rock landscape. With wid...

  • 10.00 Acres

$90,000

296 W 200 S, Monticello UT 84535

296 W 200 S
Monticello UT 84535

Move right in to this clean and cozy 3 bed 1 bath home. Located in a safe neighborhood with easy access to schools, churches, hospital, and shopping. Sturdy m...

  • 1050 Sq Ft

  • 3

  • 1

  • 1

$315,000

20 W SUNRISE COUNTRY RD, Monticello UT 84535

20 W SUNRISE COUNTRY RD
Monticello UT 84535

Sunrise Country Lot 20 near end of cul de sac in quiet neighborhood and off the grid. HOA with Covenants to protect land values. Planted in perennial grasses a...

  • 35.08 Acres

$75,000

297 S NORTHCREEK LN, Monticello UT 84535

297 S NORTHCREEK LN
Monticello UT 84535

Recently remodeled home for sale in Monticello. 5 bedroom, 3 bath. 3,420 square feet. Large kitchen, deep set sink, and large island with additional butler pant...

  • 3420 Sq Ft

  • 5

  • 3

  • 2

$459,900

388 N MAIN ST, Monticello UT 84535

388 N MAIN ST
Monticello UT 84535





  • 1149 Sq Ft

  • 2

  • 1

$264,900

17 W SUNRISE COUNTRY RD, Monticello UT 84535

17 W SUNRISE COUNTRY RD
Monticello UT 84535

Sunrise Country lot at Deerneck Mesa is in Greenbelt Tax designation. Great Southern exposure for great solar and wind power possibilities. Awesome views of LaS...

  • 36.40 Acres

$80,000

49 E 400 S, Monticello UT 84535

49 E 400 S
Monticello UT 84535

Nestled on a peaceful road just off of Main Street, this charming tri-level home offers a unique and cozy living space. Step inside to find a spacious kitchen o...

  • 2949 Sq Ft

  • 4

  • 2

$329,000

133 S 300 E, Monticello UT 84535

133 S 300 E
Monticello UT 84535

Discover the perfect property on over half an acre, centrally located in Monticello and right next to the local nursery, an ideal setting for gardening enthusia...

  • 2668 Sq Ft

  • 5

  • 3

  • 2

$349,000

10.0k

NORTH CREEK RD, Monticello UT 84535

NORTH CREEK RD
Monticello UT 84535

Beautiful mountain lot on the Blue Mountains, adorned by huge pine trees, juniper, and oakbrush with all the feels of the mountainside but less than 2 miles fro...

  • 18.89 Acres

$179,000

, Monticello UT 84535


Monticello UT 84535

Own a beautiful 253.57-acre piece of the quiet Eastland community, perfectly located between monticello and dove creek. This expansive property offers the ideal...

  • 253.57 Acres

$279,000

11 N SAGE DR, Monticello UT 84535

11 N SAGE DR
Monticello UT 84535

Country living at its best! 5 acres of natural juniper, sage and pinyon pine covered landscape in the heart of Eastland Community. So many possibilities. Build ...

  • 1600 Sq Ft

  • 4

  • 2

  • 10

$259,000

450  EAST, Monticello UT 84535

450 EAST
Monticello UT 84535

Presenting a remarkable opportunity to acquire prime land in the desirable Monticello area. This exceptional property boasts unobstructed, panoramic views of th...

  • 4.21 Acres

$129,000

450  EAST, Monticello UT 84535

450 EAST
Monticello UT 84535

Presenting a remarkable opportunity to acquire prime land in the desirable Monticello area. This exceptional property boasts unobstructed, panoramic views of th...

  • 4.19 Acres

$129,000

450  EAST, Monticello UT 84535

450 EAST
Monticello UT 84535

Presenting a remarkable opportunity to acquire prime land in the desirable Monticello area. This exceptional property boasts unobstructed, panoramic views of th...

  • 4.18 Acres

$129,000

332 N MAIN ST, Monticello UT 84535

332 N MAIN ST
Monticello UT 84535

Commercial lot with main street frontage in Monticello - which is located in the middle of some of the most picturesque areas in the United States including Mes...

  • 0.73 Acres

$249,000

317 S NORTHCREEK LN, Monticello UT 84535

317 S NORTHCREEK LN
Monticello UT 84535

Wonderful Lot. Beautiful mountain views. The house next door can be bought in addition to this lot. MLS# 2109123 /Parcel # A00170000060. Call Agent For correct...

  • 0.22 Acres

$49,900

1165 N UCOLO RD, Monticello UT 84535

1165 N UCOLO RD
Monticello UT 84535





  • 2304 Sq Ft

  • 3

  • 2

  • 1

$358,900

100

196 S BLUE MOUNTAIN DR, Monticello UT 84535

196 S BLUE MOUNTAIN DR
Monticello UT 84535





  • 2430 Sq Ft

  • 4

  • 3

$315,000

450  EAST, Monticello UT 84535

450 EAST
Monticello UT 84535

Presenting a remarkable opportunity to acquire prime land in the desirable Monticello area. This exceptional property boasts unobstructed, panoramic views of th...

  • 4.23 Acres

$129,000

264 S LATIGO LOOP, Monticello UT 84535

264 S LATIGO LOOP
Monticello UT 84535

Great Location! Wonderful Neighborhood! Welcome home! This charming property is the ideal choice for buyers looking to plant roots in a quiet, welcoming subdiv...

  • 1920 Sq Ft

  • 2

  • 1

  • 1

$384,900

, Monticello UT 84535


Monticello UT 84535

Beautiful investment property ... road to property, and private area to build a home. 33 + acres of hunting property near coal bed canyon with plenty of room t...

  • 33.00 Acres

$70,000

1000 N COUNTY ROAD 314, Monticello UT 84535

1000 N COUNTY ROAD 314
Monticello UT 84535

Expansive fully fenced agricultural grazing land with sweeping views of the surrounding mountain ranges including the Blues and La Sal Mountains in Utah and ove...

  • 330.00 Acres

$280,500

Homes Under $500K in Monticello

Looking for homes under $500k in Monticello, Utah? We currently have 34 listings matching your criteria. New properties are added daily, so check back often or create a custom search to get notified of new listings.

Best Utah Real Estate Mobile App
MLS at your fingertips
Real-time updates
Listing Alerts
Interactive Map
Save your searches

Best Utah Real Estate

Your trusted MLS search companion

Accurate Data - Direct MLS feed for real-time listings
Privacy First - We never sell your personal data
Personalized - Custom alerts for your dream home
Easy to Use - Intuitive design for all users