bds
|
ba
|
sqft
ac lot
|
car garage
|
|
Investment Properties for Sale in Lake Shore, Utah
Lake Shore is a small agricultural community tucked between Spanish Fork, Benjamin, and the southern shore of Utah Lake. It's unincorporated Utah County, which means lower density, larger lots, irrigation ditches running between properties, and a noticeably different feel from the subdivisions creeping south from Provo. For investors, that translates to a specific opportunity set: single-family rentals on a quarter-acre to a few acres, older farmhouses with shops or outbuildings, and land parcels sitting in the path of growth as Spanish Fork annexes south. Tenant demand is steady because Lake Shore puts renters within a 10–25 minute commute of Spanish Fork, Provo/BYU, Payson Hospital, and the Lehi tech corridor, while still offering the rural pace families with kids, animals, or trailers actively look for.
Underwriting here requires a little more homework than a tract home in Saratoga Springs. Water rights, secondary irrigation shares, well status, septic condition, and flood-zone proximity to Utah Lake all matter and can swing a deal's economics. Zoning is also worth a careful read — some parcels allow accessory dwellings, livestock, or future subdivision, and some don't. Cash flow tends to be modest at current prices, but appreciation potential is real given how quickly southern Utah County is growing. Browse the active Lake Shore listings below to see what's currently on the market, and reach out if you'd like help running numbers on a specific property.
January 2026 · Lake Shore market
Live from the Utah MLS — what's actually happening in Lake Shore right now.
Median sale
$625,000
1 closed in January 2026
Median DOM
183 days
listing → contract
Sale-to-list
97.7%
of final list price
Unsold inventory
—
active + pending
1 matching · page 1 of 1
Active listings
Prefer the map?
See all 1 investment properties on a map
Pan around Lake Shore and refine by drawing your own boundary.
Common questions
About investment properties in Lake Shore.
What kind of investment properties are typical in Lake Shore? ▾
Lake Shore is a rural pocket of southern Utah County between Spanish Fork and Benjamin, so inventory leans toward single-family homes on larger lots, small acreage parcels, and the occasional farmhouse with outbuildings. Long-term rentals to families working in Spanish Fork, Payson, or the Geneva/Vineyard tech corridor make up most of the rental demand. True multi-family buildings are rare — most investors here buy SFRs or land with development potential.
What rents can a landlord realistically charge in Lake Shore? ▾
Three- and four-bedroom homes in the Lake Shore/Spanish Fork area generally rent in the $2,000–$2,700 range depending on size, age, and acreage. Homes with a shop, pasture, or room for horses tend to pull a premium because that inventory is limited along the Wasatch Front. Vacancy is typically low given the area's proximity to I-15 and Provo employers.
Is short-term rental (Airbnb) a viable strategy here? ▾
Lake Shore is unincorporated Utah County, so short-term rental rules differ from incorporated cities like Spanish Fork or Payson. The area is quiet and agricultural rather than tourist-driven, so STR demand is thinner than in Park City or Moab. Most investors who try nightly rentals here target visiting families, hunters, or guests attending events at the Spanish Fork Fairgrounds.
Are there development or land-banking opportunities in Lake Shore? ▾
Yes — Lake Shore sits in the path of growth heading south from Spanish Fork, and several parcels have been rezoned or annexed in recent years. Investors buying raw land or older homes on 1–5 acres are often playing a longer game tied to future subdivision potential. Check current zoning with Utah County and water share availability before underwriting any land deal.
What should I know about water rights when buying investment property here? ▾
Water is a real underwriting issue in Lake Shore. Many properties rely on well water, secondary irrigation from Strawberry Highline or local canal companies, and recorded shares that don't always transfer automatically. Confirm culinary source, irrigation shares, and any well permits in writing before closing — a property without adequate water rights can be very hard to rent or develop.
How close is Lake Shore to major employers that drive rental demand? ▾
Lake Shore is about 10 minutes from downtown Spanish Fork, 20 minutes to Provo and BYU, and roughly 25–30 minutes to the Silicon Slopes corridor in Lehi. That puts tenants within reasonable commute of healthcare, tech, manufacturing, and university jobs, which keeps demand for clean 3–4 bedroom rentals steady year-round.