4+ Bedroom Homes for Sale in Plymouth, Utah

Plymouth sits in the northern reaches of Box Elder County, about 20 miles south of the Idaho line and roughly 90 minutes from Salt Lake City International. It's a small farming community of fewer than 500 residents, surrounded by working acreage, hay fields, and the kind of wide-open Cache Valley views that have largely disappeared from the Wasatch Front. Buyers shopping for 4+ bedroom homes here are usually looking for something specific: room for a growing family, multigenerational living, or a home office plus guest space, all on a parcel where kids can actually run. Larger homes in Plymouth tend to sit on half-acre to multi-acre lots, often with outbuildings, room for horses, or established gardens — features that would cost a fortune closer to Logan or Brigham City.

The trade-off is real and worth naming: you're committing to a rural lifestyle with a longer drive to grocery runs in Tremonton (about 10 minutes) and to bigger employers along the I-15 corridor. Kids attend Bear River School District schools, and winters here bring genuine snow and cold valley inversions, while summers stay dry and warm. Pricing on 4-bedroom properties typically runs well below comparable square footage in Cache Valley proper, which is part of why Plymouth keeps drawing buyers priced out of areas farther south. Browse the active listings below to see what's currently available, and reach out if you'd like to walk through any of them in person.