Stillwater Homes For Sale

Stillwater is a small Saratoga Springs subdivision built mostly between 2010 and 2019, with homes averaging a 2012 build year, roughly 4,162 square feet of living area, and quarter-acre lots near 10,890 square feet. Sales activity is thin, with just 13 closings tracked over the past year, so single transactions move the median noticeably; recent sale prices have ranged from $660,000 in March 2026 to $1,066,500 in September 2025, and the four October 2025 closings settled at a median of $797,500 with only 8 days on market and a 96.71% sale-to-list ratio. New listing activity has picked up into spring, with six homes coming to market in May 2026 at a median list price of $719,850. Nearly all homes here feed Sage Hills Elementary and Westlake High (93% each), with most also assigned to Lake Mountain Middle, and the HOA runs a modest $75 per month.