Get App
Call 801-410-7917

Garden City, Utah

What Is My Garden City, Utah Home Worth?

Get a free, no-obligation valuation of your Garden City home from a local expert — not an automated guess. We price it against the homes actually selling in your neighborhood right now.

  • Comparable sales from your part of Garden City
  • A price range and a strategy for your timeline
  • A short call, video or in-person visit
  • No obligation, no listing pressure

Garden City home values right now

What Garden City homes are actually selling for

The quickest way to sanity-check any number you've seen for your house is to look at what the market is doing now. These figures come from closed sales in the MLS and refresh automatically.

Full Garden City market report →
Median sale, October 2026
$504,425
up 39.0% from a year earlier
Sale price vs. list price
95.5%
October 2026 closings
Typical days to sell
70 days
median, listing to contract
Months of supply
14.5
homes for sale ÷ monthly closings

12 residential sales closed in October 2026. Typical asking price today: $654,500. 174 homes for sale. Year-over-year compares October 2026 with the same month last year.

Are Garden City home prices dropping?

No. The median sale price is up about 39.0% from the same month a year ago. One month's median moves with whichever homes happened to sell, so read it as a direction, not a precise change for your home. Rising medians still don't lift every home equally, so your own comparable sales matter more than the citywide number.

Is Garden City a buyer's or seller's market?

With about 14.5 months of supply, the market leans toward buyers. Under about four months usually favors sellers; over six favors buyers. Homes are closing at about 95.5% of list price, so buyers are negotiating harder than they were. The citywide number hides a lot. A move-in-ready home in a popular neighborhood can still draw quick offers while a dated one nearby waits, and that gap is what a home-by-home analysis is for.

Median sale prices by neighborhood in Garden City

NeighborhoodMedian sale priceHomes soldFor sale now
Sweetwater Park $715,000 34 40
Omega $776,000 14 12
Swan Creek $711,000 10 7
Sweetwater $631,000 7 3

Closed residential sales over the last 12 months, from the MLS. Neighborhoods with fewer than five sales aren't shown. Area medians are a starting point, not an answer: two homes on the same street can sell far apart once size, lot, layout and condition are counted, and a median moves with whatever mix of homes happened to sell.

Selling a home in Garden City

Garden City sits on the west shore of Bear Lake, the "Caribbean of the Rockies," about 40 miles over Logan Canyon from Logan. It's a small town with a year-round population under 900 and a summer population many times that: in the 2020 Census, about three of every four homes here were seasonal or second homes. That makes Garden City a second-home and vacation-rental market first, and the questions that drive value here are different from almost anywhere else in Utah.

Lake views and lake access, distance to the marina and beaches, nightly rental licensing and HOA rules, and how a cabin is set up for large summer groups all matter as much as square footage. Communities like Sweetwater Park, Swan Creek Village and Omega sell differently, as the neighborhood table above shows, and the market is seasonal, with most buyers shopping in spring and summer.

Not every listing with a Garden City address is in town. Sweetwater and other areas outside town limits follow Rich County rules, and the towns on the north shore are in Idaho. A CMA from a local agent sorts out the jurisdiction and licensing first, then prices your property against the sales that truly compare.

Local factors

What moves home values in Garden City

National valuation tools treat a square foot the same everywhere. Buyers here don't. These are the details that most often separate two Garden City homes that look identical on paper.

Nightly rental licensing

Garden City licenses short-term rentals in all zones unless an HOA prohibits them, with no owner-occupancy requirement. New license applications are only accepted January 1 through April 30, and a license doesn't transfer to a buyer: a new owner has to apply for their own. That timing matters for anyone buying a cabin to rent.

HOA rental rules

Some HOAs have opted out of short-term rentals by filing their CC&Rs with the town. A property in a rental-friendly HOA sells to investors and vacation buyers; one in a no-rental HOA sells mostly to personal-use buyers.

Lake views and access

Bear Lake views, walkable beach access and proximity to the state park marina carry big premiums. Lakefront claims need a survey, since the town limits building near the lake's high-water line.

Setup for summer groups

Rental and family buyers pay for sleeping capacity, bathrooms, parking for boats and trailers, and outdoor space. Licensed occupancy is capped by sleeping area and parking, so those features directly affect rental value.

ADUs

Garden City allows internal ADUs in all residential zones and detached ADUs on lots over 11,000 square feet, on owner-occupied properties with a yearly town permit. ADUs can't be used as short-term rentals.

Seasonality and winter

Most buyers shop in spring and summer, and winter access over Logan Canyon and snow on the roads and roofs affect cabins differently. Listing timing and winterization both matter.

Second-home taxes

Second homes and nightly rentals don't get Utah's 45% primary-residence exemption and are taxed on full value. Buyers comparing a Utah cabin with one across the Idaho line also face different state rules.

Garden City home value FAQs

How much is my Garden City home or cabin worth? +
It depends on lake views and access, size and sleeping capacity, rental licensing and HOA rules, condition and the most recent comparable sales. In Garden City, the latest median sale price is $504,425, but with a seasonal market and a small number of sales, every property needs its own analysis.
Can I rent my Garden City property nightly? +
Yes, with a town short-term rental license, in any zone unless your HOA prohibits short-term rentals. New applications are accepted only January 1 through April 30, and licenses don't transfer when a property sells. ADUs can't be used as short-term rentals.
Does a short-term rental license transfer to the buyer? +
No. A buyer of a licensed rental has to apply for their own license during the January 1 to April 30 window. A temporary permit lets a new owner honor existing bookings only through December 31 of that year, so plan the sale around it.
How long does it take to sell a home in Garden City? +
Longer than in most of Utah. Homes are currently taking a median of 70 days to go under contract, and the market is strongly seasonal, with most buyers active in spring and summer.
Is Sweetwater part of Garden City? +
Sweetwater and other areas around the lake can carry Garden City addresses but sit outside town limits under Rich County rules, and the north-shore towns are in Idaho. Rental, ADU and zoning rules depend on the property's actual jurisdiction, so check the parcel record.
Is an online estimate accurate for a Bear Lake property? +
Not very. Utah is a non-disclosure state, so online tools can't see sale prices, and Garden City's seasonal market, lake views and rental rules make automated estimates especially unreliable.

Ready to know what your Garden City home is worth?

A local expert valuation beats any online estimate — and it's free.

Market figures are sourced from the Regional Multiple Listing Service and refreshed regularly; information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. A home valuation is an estimate, not an appraisal.